An-Noor 24:61

"There is not upon the blind [any] constraint nor upon the lame constraint nor upon the ill constraint nor upon yourselves when you eat from your [own] houses or the houses of your fathers or the houses of your mothers or the houses of your brothers or the houses of your sisters or the houses of your father's brothers or the houses of your father's sisters or the houses of your mother's brothers or the houses of your mother's sisters or [from houses] whose keys you possess or [from the house] of your friend. There is no blame upon you whether you eat together or separately. But when you enter houses, give greetings of peace upon each other - a greeting from Allāh, blessed and good. Thus does Allāh make clear to you the verses [of ordinance] that you may understand."

Eating from One's Relatives' Houses

What is referred to here is the fact that they used to feel too embarrassed to eat with the blind, because they could not see the food or where the best morsels were, so others might take the best pieces before they could. They felt too embarrassed to eat with the lame because they could not sit comfortably, and their companions might take advantage of them, and they felt embarrassed to eat with the sick because they might not eat as much as others. So they were afraid to eat with them lest they were unfair to them in some way. Then Allah revealed this Ayah, granting them a dispensation in this matter. This was the view of Sa`id bin Jubayr and Miqsam. Ad-Dahhak said: "Before the Prophet's Mission, they used to feel too embarrassed and too proud to eat with these people, lest they might have to help them. So Allah revealed this Ayah."

لَّيْسَ عَلَى الاٌّعْمَى حَرَجٌ

(nor any restriction on the lame,) `Abdur-Razzaq recorded that Mujahid said: "A man would take a blind, lame or sick person to the house of his brother or sister or aunt, and those disabled people would feel ashamed of that and say, `they are taking us to other people's houses.' So this Ayah was revealed granting permission for that." As-Suddi said: "A man would enter the house of his father or brother or son, and the lady of the house would bring him some food, but he would refrain from eating because the master of the house was not there, so Allah revealed:

لَّيْسَ عَلَى الاٌّعْمَى حَرَجٌ

(There is no restriction on the blind. ..)

وَلاَ عَلَى أَنفُسِكُمْ أَن تَأْكُلُواْ مِن بُيُوتِكُمْ

(nor on yourselves, if you eat from your houses,) This is stated here although it is obvious, so that from this starting point the houses of others may be mentioned, and to make it clear that the ruling applies equally to what comes after. Sons' houses are included in this even though they are not mentioned by name, and this is used as evidence by those who regard the son's wealth as being like the father's wealth. In the Musnad and the Sunan, it is reported through several routes that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:

«أَنْتَ وَمَالُكَ لِأَبِيكَ»

(You and your wealth belong to your father.)

أَوْ بُيُوتِ ءَابَآئِكُمْ أَوْ بُيُوتِ أُمَّهَـتِكُمْ

(or the houses of your fathers, or the houses of your mothers,) until His statement;

أَوْ مَا مَلَكْتُم مَّفَاتِحهُ

(or (from that) whereof you hold keys,) This is obvious, and this is used as evidence by those who think that it is obligatory for relatives to spend on one another.

أَوْ مَا مَلَكْتُم مَّفَاتِحهُ

(or (from that) whereof you hold keys,) Sa`id bin Jubayr and As-Suddi said, "This refers to a people's servants, whether a slave or otherwise. There is nothing wrong with them eating from the food that is stored with them, within reason." Az-Zuhri narrated from `Urwah that `A'isha, may Allah be pleased with her, said, "The Muslims used to go out on military campaigns with the Messenger of Allah ﷺ and they would give their keys to people they trusted and say, `We permit you to eat whatever you need.' But they would say, `It is not permissible for us to eat, they have given us permission reluctantly and we are only trustees.' Then Allah revealed:

أَوْ مَا مَلَكْتُم مَّفَاتِحهُ

(or (from that) whereof you hold keys)."

أَوْ صَدِيقِكُمْ

(or (from the house) of a friend.) means, there is no sin on you if you eat from their houses, so long as you know that this does not upset them and they do not dislike it.

لَيْسَ عَلَيْكُمْ جُنَاحٌ أَن تَأْكُلُواْ جَمِيعاً أَوْ أَشْتَاتاً

(No sin on you whether you eat together or apart.) `Ali bin Abi Talhah reported from Ibn `Abbas concerning this Ayah, "When Allah revealed the Ayah:

يَـأَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ ءَامَنُواْ لاَ تَأْكُلُواْ أَمْوَلَكُمْ بَيْنَكُمْ بِالْبَـطِلِ

(O you who believe! Eat not up your property among yourselves unjustly) 4: 29, the Muslims said, `Allah has forbidden us to eat up our property among ourselves unjustly, and food is the best of property, so it is not permissible for anyone among us to eat at the house of anyone else.' So the people stopped doing that. Then Allah revealed:

لَّيْسَ عَلَى الاٌّعْمَى حَرَجٌ

(There is no restriction on the blind,) until His statement;

أَوْ صَدِيقِكُمْ

(or (from the house) of a friend.) A man would also feel embarrassed and would refrain from eating alone until someone else came along, but Allah made the matter easier for them and said:

لَيْسَ عَلَيْكُمْ جُنَاحٌ أَن تَأْكُلُواْ جَمِيعاً أَوْ أَشْتَاتاً

(No sin on you whether you eat together or apart.)" Qatadah said, "This was a clan of Banu Kinanah who during the Jahiliyyah thought that it was a source of shame for one of them to eat alone, to such an extent that a man might keep on driving his laden camel even though he was hungry, until he could find someone to eat and drink with him. Then Allah revealed:

لَيْسَ عَلَيْكُمْ جُنَاحٌ أَن تَأْكُلُواْ جَمِيعاً أَوْ أَشْتَاتاً

(No sin on you whether you eat together or apart.) So this was a dispensation from Allah, allowing people to eat either alone or with others, even though eating with others is more blessed and is better. Imam Ahmad recorded from Wahshi bin Harb from his father from his grandfather that a man said to the Prophet , "We eat but we do not feel satisfied." He said:

«لَعَلَّكُمْ تَأْكُلُونَ مُتَفَرِّقِينَ، اجْتَمِعُوا عَلَى طَعَامِكُمْ، وَاذْكُرُوا اسْمَ اللهِ، يُبَارَكْ لَكُمْ فِيهِ»

(Perhaps you are eating separately. Eat together and mention the Name of Allah, and He will bless the food for you.) It was also recorded by Abu Dawud and Ibn Majah. Ibn Majah also recorded that Salim reported from his father from `Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:

«كُلُوا جَمِيعًا، وَلَا تَفَرَّقُوا، فَإِنَّ الْبَرَكَةَ مَعَ الْجَمَاعَةِ»

(Eat together and not separately, for the blessing is in being together.)

فَإِذَا دَخَلْتُمْ بُيُوتاً فَسَلِّمُواْ عَلَى أَنفُسِكُمْ

(But when you enter the houses, greet one another) Sa`id bin Jubayr, Al-Hasan Al-Basri, Qatadah and Az-Zuhri said, "This means greet one another with Salam." Ibn Jurayj said: Abu Az-Zubayr said, "I heard Jabir bin `Abdullah say, `When you enter upon your family, greet them with a greeting from Allah, blessed and good.' He said, `I do not think it is anything but obligatory."' Ibn Jurayj said: "And Ziyad said that Ibn Tawus used to say: `When any one of you enters his house, let him say Salam."' Mujahid said: "And when you enter the Masjid, say: `Peace be upon the Messenger of Allah ﷺ'; when you enter upon your families, greet them with Salam; and when you enter a house in which there is nobody, say: `As-Salamu `Alayna wa `Ala `Ibad-Allah-is-Salihin (peace be upon us and upon the righteous servants of Allah).' This is what one is commanded to do, and it has been narrated to us that the angels will return his greeting."

كَذَلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ اللَّهُ لَكُمُ الاٌّيَـتِ لَعَلَّكُمْ تَعْقِلُونَ

(Thus Allah makes clear the Ayat to you that you may understand.) When Allah mentioned what wise rulings and reasonable, well-constructed laws are contained in this Surah, He points out to His servants that He explains the Ayat to them clearly so that they may ponder them and understand their meanings.

Всевышний поведал о Своей милости по отношению к рабам. Он не только не сделал религию обременительной для людей, но и облегчил религиозные предписания. Ни слепые, ни хромые, ни больные мусульмане не совершат греха, если оставят некоторые обязательные религиозные предписания. Это может быть священная война на пути Аллаха или другой обряд поклонения, который слепой не способен выполнить из-за отсутствия зрения, хромой - из-за хромоты, а больной - по состоянию здоровья. Это откровение имеет самый широкий смысл и распространяется на все шариатские предписания. Однако затем Всевышний Аллах ниспослал повеление, которое действительно только при определенных обстоятельствах. Всевышний разрешил мусульманам есть в своих собственных домах, под которыми подразумеваются дома их детей. О справедливости этого утверждения свидетельствуют слова Пророка Мухаммада, который сказал: «Ты вместе со своим имуществом принадлежишь твоему отцу». А в другом хадисе говорится: «Лучшей пищей является то, что вы заработали собственным трудом, и ваши дети также являются вашим заработком и приобретением». В этом откровении не имеются в виду собственные дома людей, потому что это означало бы разъяснение того, что не нуждается в разъяснении. А речь Аллаха бесконечно далека от подобных бесполезных выражений. Аллах разъяснил то, что не является грехом, но может вызвать сомнения у некоторых людей. Что же касается собственного дома, то никто не станет сомневаться в том, что человек имеет право есть в своем собственном доме. Всевышний также разрешил Своим рабам есть в домах отцов, или в домах матерей, или в домах братьев, или в домах сестер, или в домах дядей по отцу, или в домах теток по отцу, или в домах дядей по матери, или в домах теток по матери, или в тех домах, ключи которых находятся в их распоряжении, или в домах друзей. Под домами, ключи которых находятся в распоряжении людей, подразумеваются дома, которыми человек распоряжается по доверенности, в связи с опекунством или по другим подобным причинам. Что же касается толкования, согласно которому под этими домами подразумеваются дома принадлежащих людям рабов, то оно не является достоверным по двум причинам. Во-первых, дом раба не называют домом, ключи которого находятся в распоряжении человека. Человек распоряжается домом своего раба целиком и полностью, а не только его ключами. А Во-вторых, дом раба является собственным домом хозяина раба, потому что раб вместе со своим имуществом полностью принадлежит своему господину. И поэтому ничто не мешает человеку есть в доме своего раба. Мусульманин имеет право поесть в одном из перечисленных домов даже без разрешения хозяина дома, и мудрость этого предписания становится ясна из контекста этого откровения. Согласно существующим обычаям, люди позволяют друг другу поступать так, потому что их связывают родство, хозяйственные взаимоотношения или дружба. И если бы перечисленные выше люди проявляли скупость по отношению друг к другу и не позволяли друг другу поесть в своем доме, то Аллах не ниспослал бы этого дозволения. Об этом свидетельствуют смысл и мудрость обсуждаемого нами откровения. Всевышний также отметил, что мусульмане могут есть вместе или в отдельности. Это сделано для того, чтобы не обременять мусульман дополнительными ограничениями, а не потому, что между трапезой в кругу людей и в уединении нет никакой разницы. Поэтому следует знать, что предпочтительнее трапезничать в кругу людей. Затем Всевышний Аллах повелел мусульманам при входе в дом приветствовать друг друга миром. Арабское слово «буйут» («дома») использовано в условном предложении без определенного артикля, и это означает, что ниспосланное предписание относится ко всем домам без исключения, даже если в них никого нет. Примечательно, что Аллах повелел мусульманам приветствовать самих себя, потому что взаимная любовь и милосердие мусульман делают их единым целым. Из всего сказанного следует, что произносить слова приветствия следует при входе в любой дом без исключения, тогда как просить разрешения войти нужно не во всех случаях. Затем Аллах похвалил мусульманское приветствие и назвал его благословенным и прекрасным. И поэтому при входе в дом мусульмане говорят: «Мир вам, милость и благословение Аллаха!» Можно также сказать: «Мир нам и праведным рабам Аллаха!» Аллах повелел приветствовать мусульман таким образом и сделал эти слова благословенными, потому что в них содержатся пожелания благополучия, милости, благословения, преуспеяния и приумножения добра. Аллах также назвал эти слова прекрасными, потому что они угодны Самому Аллаху, доставляют радость тому, кого приветствуют, и порождают взаимную любовь и симпатию. Так Аллах разъясняет Свои знамения, свидетельствующие о мудрости религиозных предписаний. Быть может, это заставит людей призадуматься и поразмыслить. Это может сделать из них благоразумных и сознательных людей, потому что размышления над истинными шариатскими предписаниями делают человека более разумным и сознательным. Это связано с тем, что шариатские предписания имеют самый славный смысл и проповедуют самое правильное поведение. А воздаяние от Аллаха всегда соответствует роду совершенных деяний. И если человек, повинуясь призыву Всевышнего, использовал свой разум для познания своего Господа и размышления о Его знамениях, то Аллах сделает его еще более проницательным и благоразумным. Из этого аята вытекает важное шариатское правило, которое гласит: «Обычай и обыкновение определяются словами». В принципе, человек не имеет права есть то, что принадлежит другому человеку. Однако Аллах разрешил Своим рабам есть в домах перечисленных в откровении людей, потому что это полностью соответствует сложившимся обычаям. Из этого следует, что если человек должен попросить у хозяина разрешение на пользование его собственностью, но уверен в том, что хозяин позволит ему это, то ему разрешается воспользоваться этой собственностью. Из этого аята также следует, что отец имеет право пользоваться собственностью своего сына или присваивать ее себе, если подобный поступок не причиняет вреда его сыну, потому что Аллах назвал дома сыновей собственными домами родителей. Из него также следует, что супруга хозяина дома, сестра хозяина дома или любой другой человек, который распоряжается в его доме, имеют право есть в этом доме и кормить нуждающихся в пределах, определяемых обыкновением. Из него также следует, что люди имеют право скидываться для того, чтобы пообедать вместе, даже если один из них поест больше других.

Commentary

Some injunctions and social etiquettes after the entry in the house

In the previous verses it was enjoined to seek permission before entering into anyone's house. In the above verse those injunctions and etiquettes are pronounced which are obligatory or preferable to follow after the permission to enter the house is granted. Before understanding the injunction contained in this verse and its purport it would be advisable to know the background in which this verse was revealed.

Every Muslim knows very well how much emphasis is laid by the Holy Qur'an and the teachings of the Holy Prophet ﷺ for respecting and preserving the rights of the people (Huquq ul-` Ibad). Very strong warnings are sounded against using anything owned by someone else without his permission. On the other hand Allah Ta’ ala had chosen such fortunate persons for the company of the Holy Prophet ﷺ that they were all ears for any command from Allah or His Messenger. They were always ready to put in their best on every single command. By following Qur'anic teachings diligently and having the exalted company of the Holy Prophet ﷺ they were turned by Allah Ta’ ala into a group of whom even the angels were proud. Not to think ever to spend even slightly from other's wealth, to avoid putting in anyone into the slightest of trouble and to remain steadfast on the highest standard of Taqwa (constant awareness of Allah) were only some of the attributes of the companions of the Holy Prophet ﷺ . Some related incidents had taken place during the life of the Holy Prophet ﷺ ، in which connection the injunctions contained in the present verse were revealed. All commentators have made reference of these incidents with the difference that different incidents are quoted as the cause of revelation by different commentators. The actual position is that there is no contradiction in their assertions, and all these incidents put together are the cause of revelation of this verse. The incidents are as follows:

Imam Baghawi (رح) has related on authority of Said Ibn Jubair ؓ and some other commentators that it is a common habit among people to feel disgust in eating together with lame, cripple, blind and sick, and avoid it. Among the companions who had any of these disability thought that if they were to eat with others they might cause botheration and trouble to them. Therefore, they started avoiding eating with normal persons. The blind people thought that they might eat more than others, as they cannot see, causing injustice for the rest. Justice requires that all who eat together should eat equally. Likewise, the lame thought that they would create problem for others as they could not sit properly and occupy more space, which will result in taking up the share of space of others. In this background, the above verse was revealed in which the disabled were asked to join other normal persons for eating. They were advised not to take upon themselves such painstaking precautionary measures which could lead them into trouble.

Imam Baghawi (رح) has narrated another incident related by Ibn Jarir on authority of Sayyidna Ibn ` Abbas ؓ which presents the other side of the picture. The story goes like this; when the verse لَا تَأْكُلُوا أَمْوَالَكُم بَيْنَكُم بِالْبَاطِلِ (Do not eat up each other's property by false means - 2:188) was revealed, people were hesitant to eat with the blind, lame and the sick. Their consideration was that the sick eats less because of his indisposition, so he would suffer if he eats with others. The blind cannot differentiate between the good and ordinary food, and the lame is slow to eat because of his posture. So, people thought there is a possibility that the disabled are deprived of their due share, whereas the justice demands that all should eat equally while eating together. So, it was in this background that this verse was revealed, and people were taken out of this predicament. The spirit behind this injunction is that people should eat together and if there is a little disparity in the quantity of food taken by each one of them, it should not be a cause of botheration.

Said Ibn al-Musayyab ؓ has given yet another version that while going on jihad or battles, the Muslims used to hand over the keys of their houses to the disabled with the instructions that they can eat whatever is there in the house. On the other hand, the disabled would not eat anything, lest they spend something against the wishes of the owners. Hence, to counter this position, the above verse was revealed. Musnad al-Bazzar has also reported this version on the authority of Sayyidah ` A'ishah ؓ that when the Holy Prophet ﷺ used to go on a battle, it was the desire of every companion to go along with him to participate in the battle. They used to hand over the keys of their houses to the poor and disabled persons with the permission that they could eat anything available in the house during their absence. But the disabled would abstain from taking anything from the house fearing that the permission given to them to eat freely from the house might not have been given with full willingness. Baghawi has also narrated on authority of Sayyidna Ibn ` Abbas ؓ that the word صَدِیقَکُم (your friend) used in the verse, which means that there is no harm in eating from your friend's house, was a reference toward the incident of Harith bin ` Amr ؓ . The incident was that Hrith b. ` Amr ؓ went for jihad along with the Holy Prophet ﷺ ، leaving the care and custody of his house to his friend, Malik Ibn Zaid ؓ . When Harith returned, he noticed that Malik Ibn Zaid ؓ had become very weak. When he enquired the reason of the weakness, Malik ؓ replied that he did not feel it right to eat anything from his house. (All these narrations are taken from Tafsir Mazhari). Indeed all these incidents had a bearing on the revelation of this verse.

Ruling

As mentioned above, a general permission was granted in this verse to eat in certain houses without asking special consent. This permission was granted on the basis of a tradition among ` Arabs to eat freely in the houses of close relatives. There was absolutely no formality among them, and no one would ever mind this habit, rather they used to encourage it and would feel happy about it. Not only that, sometimes the relatives used to bring poor, sick or needy persons and feed them at houses of others, on which the hosts would feel happy. According to custom they would not seek special permission for this, as there was a general consent among them to follow the tradition. It therefore becomes obvious that wherever and whenever this tradition is not in vogue, or the owner's consent is doubtful, then eating without permission is forbidden. In the present time no one would like that even a close relative would eat in his house without seeking permission. Therefore, the permission granted in this verse would not apply, unless someone is absolutely sure that his eating in a relative's house would not cause any problem or displeasure, rather he would enjoy it. Only in this situation eating at such a house would be permissible under the dictate of this verse.

Ruling

It is now clear from the above statement that it is not right to say that this injunction was meant for the early days of Islam, and was abrogated later. The injunction is in force right from the beginning up to the date and shall always remain effective. The real condition of the application of this injunction is the certainty of permission of the owner of the house, and if that is not present, then the very basis of injunction is not available. (Mazhari).

Ruling

It has also now become clear that this injunction is not restricted only to the relatives specified in the verse, but the concession is applicable to other persons also, with the sole condition that it is certain that the owner of the house will be pleased and will not be offended if someone eats and also makes others eat without seeking prior permission. (Mazhari) These injunctions relate to the acts permitted or preferable on entering in someone’ s house after taking permission. The act of eating and drinking has been mentioned first due to its importance. The second act (mentioned in verse 64) relates to the etiquettes of entry.

The etiquette demands that as one enters the house with permission, he should greet all the Muslims present there with سلام salam. This is the purport of the words "greet your own selves", (verse 61). It is because all Muslims are a single united group. In many Sahih Ahadis great emphasis is laid on Muslims for greeting each other as an act of virtue.

Other English translations

Tafsīr · classical commentary

Eating from One's Relatives' Houses